Skip to main content

Cooper Hall Solicitors

EMAIL NOW

enquiries@cooperhallsolicitors.co.uk

CALL US

0333 777 5001

ADDRESS

Bradford: Listerhills Science Park, BD7 1HR
Blackburn: Kings Court, BB2 2DH

Medical Records Review in Negligence Claims

Medical Records Review in Negligence Claims

A medical records review is often where a potential medical negligence claim begins. When treatment has gone wrong, the records may provide the clearest account of what clinicians knew, what decisions were made and whether concerns were acted on in time. They can be difficult to read and may feel upsetting, particularly where a family is trying to understand a serious injury or a death.

For a claim in England, records alone do not automatically prove negligence. However, they allow a solicitor and independent medical expert to assess whether the care provided may have fallen below an acceptable standard and whether that failure caused avoidable harm. Cooper Hall Solicitors can provide clear guidance on the evidence needed for a medical negligence claim and the steps that may follow.

What does a medical records review involve?

A review brings together the relevant history from the organisations and professionals involved in treatment. This may include GP records, hospital notes, ambulance records, test results, scan reports, prescription charts, maternity records, mental health records and correspondence between services.

The purpose is not simply to find an error in handwriting or an administrative omission. The key questions are usually whether there was a breach of duty and, if so, whether it caused injury. For example, a delayed diagnosis may be concerning, but a claim will also need evidence that an earlier diagnosis would probably have led to a better outcome.

Records are usually considered in chronological order. This helps identify when symptoms were reported, when tests were requested or reviewed, whether referrals were made, and whether treatment changed as a patient’s condition developed. A gap in the notes may matter, but it must be considered carefully. Missing documentation is not always proof that an event did not happen, and a complete note does not by itself show that the decision was clinically appropriate.

Why records matter in a medical negligence claim

Clinical care is often delivered by several people and across more than one setting. A patient may speak to a GP, attend A&E, receive hospital treatment and later be referred for rehabilitation. The records can establish the sequence of events and identify which organisation had responsibility at each point.

They may also show whether warning signs were documented, whether observations changed, and whether a patient or relative raised concerns. In some cases, the timing is critical. A record of deteriorating symptoms, a delayed test result or an unacted-on recommendation can become central to the independent expert’s opinion.

The legal test is not whether care was perfect. Medicine involves judgement, uncertainty and risks which can occur even where appropriate care is provided. The question is generally whether the treatment fell below the standard expected of a reasonably competent clinician in that field. This is the test set out in Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee [1957] 1 WLR 582, refined by Bolitho v City and Hackney Health Authority [1998] AC 232, which requires the clinical opinion relied on to stand up to logical analysis. If care fell below that standard, the next issue is causation: on the balance of probabilities, what difference did that failure make to the patient’s outcome?

Getting copies of medical records

You can usually request your own health records from the NHS body, GP practice or private provider holding them. This is a subject access request under Article 15 of the UK GDPR and the Data Protection Act 2018, and the provider should normally respond within one month. A person with appropriate authority may be able to request records for someone else, such as a child or a person who lacks capacity. Where someone has died, the Access to Health Records Act 1990 allows the personal representative, and anyone who may have a claim arising from the death, to apply for the relevant records.

A solicitor can obtain records with the necessary authority and can make sure that the request is broad enough to cover all potentially relevant providers. This can be useful where care has involved different hospitals, community services or a GP practice. It may also avoid the problem of reviewing only part of the history and reaching conclusions too early.

Keep any documents already in your possession, including discharge letters, appointment letters, prescriptions, photographs and a diary of symptoms or conversations. These do not replace the formal records, but they can help identify dates, missing providers and important questions for the review.

What an independent medical expert does

A solicitor’s initial review identifies the issues that require clinical evidence. An appropriately qualified independent medical expert can then consider the records and provide an opinion on the standard of care and causation.

In court proceedings, expert evidence is governed by the Civil Procedure Rules, including Part 35. An expert’s overriding duty is to assist the court, not to argue for the person or organisation instructing them. That independence is important. A supportive opinion must be based on the records, the medical literature where relevant, and the expert’s professional reasoning.

More than one expert may be needed. A claim involving delayed cancer diagnosis, for example, may require evidence from a clinician addressing the earlier care and another expert considering how the delay affected prognosis or treatment. The right evidence depends on the facts. Starting with a focused review helps prevent unnecessary delay and expense.

Records are evidence, not the whole story

Medical notes can contain abbreviations, copied text, inconsistent timings and terminology that has little meaning outside clinical practice. They may also record a clinician’s account of a conversation rather than an exact transcript. This is why the records should be reviewed alongside your own recollection and, where appropriate, the recollections of relatives or carers.

Write down what you remember while events are still clear. Include dates where possible, the names or roles of people involved, what you were told, symptoms you reported, and how your condition affected daily life. Be accurate about what you do and do not recall. A clear account can assist with understanding the records, but it should not be shaped to fit them.

An apology, an adverse outcome or a complaint response may raise legitimate questions, but none of these automatically establishes legal liability. Section 2 of the Compensation Act 2006 provides that an apology does not, of itself, amount to an admission of negligence, and NHS Resolution’s Saying Sorry guidance makes the same point. The evidence still needs to show a breach of duty and causation.

Time limits and early action

Most medical negligence claims in England must be started in court within three years of the date of the injury or the date a person gained the knowledge needed to bring a claim. This is set out in sections 11 and 14 of the Limitation Act 1980. There are exceptions under section 28, including for children (where time usually runs from their 18th birthday) and people who lack mental capacity, but these rules can be complex.

The court has a discretion under section 33 of the Limitation Act 1980 to allow some claims to proceed outside the usual time limit. That discretion should not be relied upon. Obtaining records and independent expert evidence can take time, so it is sensible to seek advice as soon as you believe avoidable harm may have occurred.

A careful review can also show when a claim is unlikely to meet the legal test. That can be difficult news, but it gives patients and families an honest answer rather than encouraging a process with no proper evidential foundation.

Frequently asked questions

Can I request medical records before making a claim?

Yes. You can request access to your own records, and a solicitor can also request relevant records with your signed authority. It is usually better to obtain the full history from each relevant provider rather than relying only on discharge paperwork.

How long does a medical records review take?

It depends on the number of providers, the volume of records and the complexity of the treatment. Obtaining records may take time, and a specialist opinion may be needed before the prospects of a claim can be assessed properly.

What if the records are incomplete or wrong?

Raise the issue during the review. Missing pages, inaccurate entries and unclear timings can be significant, but their impact depends on the wider evidence. Other records, witness evidence and expert opinion may help clarify what happened.

Does poor treatment always mean I have a claim?

No. A poor experience or an unexpected outcome does not necessarily mean the legal test for negligence is met. A claim generally requires evidence of substandard care and evidence that it caused avoidable injury.

Will I have to pay for the review?

Funding options depend on the circumstances and the evidence available at an early stage. If a no win, no fee arrangement is suitable, terms apply. You should receive clear information about likely costs and risks before making decisions.

The records may feel technical, but they can turn uncertainty into a clear set of questions about the care you received and the harm that followed. For a free, confidential assessment call 0333 777 5001.